Gradual IP Warm-Up: Best Practices for New Senders

Gradually warming up a new or inactive IP address is essential for building a strong sender reputation and improving email deliverability. Without this process, ISPs may flag your emails as spam, block them, or even blacklist your domain. Here’s the key takeaway: start small and increase your email volume steadily over 15 to 60 days. This allows ISPs to recognize your sending behavior as legitimate.

Key Steps for IP Warm-Up:

• Start with 50–200 emails/day: Send emails to your most engaged recipients to build positive engagement signals.
• Increase volume gradually: Scale up email volume weekly, doubling or slightly increasing the number of emails sent.
• Monitor engagement metrics: Focus on open rates (aim for 20%+), click rates (2%+), and low complaint rates.
• Set up SPF, DKIM, and DMARC: These DNS records authenticate your emails and prevent spoofing.
• Use subdomains for outreach: Protect your main domain by using subdomains like mail.yourdomain.com.
• Automate the process: Tools like Primeforge and Warmforge handle volume increases, timing, and engagement tracking.

Common Mistakes to Avoid:

• Sending to unengaged or purchased lists.
• Scaling email volume too quickly.
• Ignoring key metrics like open and complaint rates.
• Taking long breaks (over 30 days) between campaigns.

By following these steps and avoiding common pitfalls, you can establish a trustworthy sender reputation, ensuring better deliverability and long-term success. Tools like Primeforge simplify this process by automating technical setups and volume scaling, allowing you to focus on creating engaging content.

Technical Setup Before IP Warm-Up

Before diving into your IP warm-up process, it's crucial to lay a solid technical foundation. This includes setting up proper DNS records, choosing the right IP solution, and verifying your domains.

Setting Up DNS Records

DNS records are essential for proving the legitimacy of your sending domain. The three key records you need to configure are SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. These records authenticate your emails and help prevent spoofing.

• SPF (Sender Policy Framework): This record tells email servers which IP addresses are authorized to send emails on behalf of your domain. Without it, your emails may be rejected or flagged as suspicious. For example, Google Workspace users might use an SPF record like this: v=spf1 include:_spf.google.com ~all.
• DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail): DKIM adds a digital signature to your emails, ensuring that the message remains unchanged during transit. This signature is created using a private key that you control, while the matching public key is published in your DNS records.
• DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance): DMARC works alongside SPF and DKIM, instructing email servers on how to handle messages that fail authentication. It also provides detailed reports, helping you identify unauthorized use of your domain.

Primeforge simplifies this process by automatically configuring these DNS records, ensuring your authentication is ready from the start. With this setup in place, you’re ready to choose the IP solution that fits your needs.

Dedicated vs. Shared IPs: Which to Choose

Your choice of IP - dedicated or shared - will have a significant impact on your warm-up strategy and email deliverability.

• Dedicated IPs: These give you full control over your sender reputation, but you’ll need to build that reputation from scratch. Dedicated IPs are best suited for senders planning to send at least 10,000 emails per month consistently.
• Shared IPs: These come with a pre-established reputation, which can make it easier to get started. However, your deliverability may be influenced by the practices of other users sharing the same IP.

Primeforge offers US-based IP addresses, which are particularly effective for campaigns targeting American audiences. Emails sent from US-based IPs often face less scrutiny from spam filters compared to those sent from foreign IPs. Additionally, Primeforge manages shared IPs with best practices to ensure strong deliverability, giving you the benefits of a dedicated IP without the hassle of managing the warm-up process entirely on your own.

Getting Domains and Mailboxes Ready

Once your IP strategy is in place, the next step is to verify your domains and set up mailboxes.

• Domain verification: To send emails, providers like Google and Microsoft require you to prove ownership of your domain. This typically involves adding a specific DNS record or uploading a verification file to your website.
• Domain age and history: Spam filters often scrutinize newly registered domains more closely. If possible, use domains that are at least 30–60 days old before starting your warm-up. New domains will require a longer warm-up period.
• Subdomain strategy: Protect your primary domain’s reputation by using subdomains for outreach campaigns. For example, use outreach.yourcompany.com or mail.yourcompany.com to isolate your cold email efforts from your main domain, which is likely reserved for critical communications like transactional emails.

Primeforge streamlines this process by offering Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 mailboxes that come pre-configured with proper authentication. These mailboxes leverage the strong reputations of Google and Microsoft’s infrastructure, giving your emails a head start. Features like mailbox profile pictures and bulk DNS updates further enhance your email legitimacy, ensuring consistency across all your domains.

Step-by-Step IP Warm-Up Process

Taking a slow and steady approach to warming up your IP is crucial. Rushing through this process can damage your sender reputation, making it difficult to recover for months.

Start with Small, Engaged Audiences

In the first week, send only about 50–200 emails per day. This gives email providers time to observe your sending patterns without raising spam flags. Focus on sending emails to your most engaged contacts - those who are likely to open, click, or respond.

Keep your emails relevant and authentic. Avoid overly promotional language or aggressive sales tactics that might lead recipients to mark your messages as spam. Instead, aim for content that feels personal, like helpful tips, company updates, or tailored messages that encourage natural engagement.

Using Primeforge’s US-based IP addresses can help improve deliverability by reducing the chances of emails being filtered as spam. Once you see good engagement, you can begin increasing your email volume gradually.

Increase Volume Over Time

Over the next 4–8 weeks, steadily increase your email volume. For example, you might grow from 50–200 emails per day in week one to 500–1,000 emails per day by week three. During this period, keep a close eye on key metrics like open rates, click rates, and spam complaints.

Consistency in timing and frequency is essential. Send emails at the same time each day and stick to a regular schedule. Avoid sudden spikes or irregular sending patterns, as these can raise red flags with email algorithms.

The length of your warm-up process depends on your ultimate sending goals. If you’re aiming to send 1,000 emails daily, a 4-week warm-up might be enough. But if your goal is to send over 10,000 emails per day, plan for a 6–8 week process to ensure your reputation stays intact.

Use Automation for Warm-Up

Automation can make warming up your IP much easier and more efficient. Automated tools help you manage gradual volume increases and maintain consistent timing.

For example, Warmforge integrates seamlessly with Primeforge’s infrastructure to automate the entire warm-up process. It gradually ramps up your sending volume while monitoring key metrics like engagement rates, spam complaints, and delivery success across different email providers. This ensures that your reputation builds steadily and safely.

Automation tools like Warmforge also simplify recipient management. They prioritize sending to your most engaged contacts during the critical early stages, rotate through different audience segments, and even mimic natural conversation patterns to boost engagement.

The combination of Primeforge and Warmforge creates a seamless system for building your sender reputation. Primeforge provides the technical backbone, including properly configured mailboxes and DNS records, while Warmforge handles the gradual warm-up process. This integration ensures that data flows smoothly between platforms, allowing for precise adjustments and better results.

For businesses managing multiple domains or mailboxes, automation is even more essential. Coordinating warm-up schedules across dozens of mailboxes manually is nearly impossible, but automated tools can handle this complexity. They ensure each domain and mailbox follows an optimal sending pattern, saving time and reducing errors.

Monitoring and Fixing Performance Issues

Keeping an eye on your IP warm-up progress is crucial, and the best way to do that is by tracking key engagement metrics. Mailbox providers are naturally cautious when evaluating a new sender, paying close attention to your sending habits and how recipients interact with your emails. Building a strong sender reputation takes consistent effort.

Key Metrics to Keep an Eye On

• Open rates: During the warm-up phase, aim for open rates above 20%. A high open rate shows that your audience finds your emails worth opening.
• Click rates: Strive for click rates above 2%. This tells you whether your content is resonating and encouraging action.
• Unsubscribe rates: Keep unsubscribe rates below 1%. Low unsubscribe rates mean your content is staying relevant and valuable to your subscribers.

By focusing on these metrics, you can make timely adjustments to protect and strengthen your sender reputation.

Reputation systems typically retain data for 30 days. To avoid setbacks, don’t let long gaps occur in your campaigns. If you notice a drop in performance, tweak your sending volume and frequency to get things back on track.

Best Practices and Common Mistakes in IP Warm-Up

Building a solid sender reputation for your new IP address hinges on careful planning and execution. Success in this phase comes from sticking to proven strategies while steering clear of common errors that could tarnish your reputation with ISPs.

Best Practices for New Senders

Focus on engaged audiences. Start by sending emails to subscribers who have actively opted in. This ensures your messages reach people who want to hear from you, creating positive engagement signals that ISPs value when evaluating new IPs.

Be consistent with sender identity. Use the same "From" name, email address, and domain across all campaigns during the warm-up process. This consistency helps ISPs recognize your sending behavior and builds trust over time.

Personalize your content. Craft emails that match your audience's interests. Tailored content drives higher engagement, which is critical for establishing a strong reputation during this phase.

Stick to a regular sending schedule. Gradually increase your email volume in steady, predictable increments. Avoid erratic or sudden spikes, as ISPs are more likely to trust a consistent sending pattern.

Ensure proper email authentication. Before sending your first email, confirm that SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are correctly configured. These authentication measures signal to ISPs that your emails are legitimate.

While these practices set you up for success, knowing what not to do is just as crucial.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Sending to unengaged or non-opted recipients. Targeting people who haven’t opted in can lead to spam complaints and lower engagement, both of which can harm your sender reputation. ISPs are particularly wary of this behavior from new IPs and may throttle or block your emails.

Scaling volume too quickly. Jumping to full volume within days can trigger spam filters. ISPs expect a gradual volume increase over several weeks. Sudden surges can result in deliverability issues or outright blocks.

Ignoring engagement metrics. Failing to monitor recipient interactions means you might miss warning signs, like declining engagement or rising complaints. Regularly reviewing these metrics allows you to adjust your strategy as needed.

Taking long breaks between campaigns. ISPs typically retain sender reputation data for about 30 days. If you stop sending emails for more than a month, you may need to restart the warm-up process.

Using promotional-heavy content too early. Emails packed with sales pitches can hurt engagement during the warm-up phase. Instead, focus on providing informative and valuable content to encourage interaction and build trust.

Comparison: Best Practices vs. Common Mistakes

A strong sender reputation doesn’t happen overnight. It requires consistent effort and adherence to best practices. By gradually increasing volume and focusing on engaged recipients, you can establish trust with ISPs. On the flip side, common mistakes like sending to unengaged lists or scaling too quickly can derail your progress.

Primeforge’s infrastructure, combined with Warmforge’s automated warm-up tools, takes the technical complexities off your plate. This allows you to focus on creating engaging content while ensuring your emails are delivered and your reputation grows steadily.

Conclusion

Gradually warming up your IP is the cornerstone of successful email outreach. While the process requires careful planning, patience, and attention to detail, the rewards are undeniable: better deliverability, a stronger sender reputation, and lasting success in your campaigns.

To recap, start small - sending about 100 emails per day to engaged recipients - and steadily increase your volume over a period of 15 to 60 days. Keep a close eye on key metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and complaint rates every day. This vigilance helps you spot and address potential issues early, protecting your sender reputation. Consistency is key, as is ensuring your technical setup - like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records - is properly configured before sending your first email.

Skipping or rushing this process can lead to serious setbacks. New IPs that scale too quickly risk triggering spam filters, landing on blacklists, or struggling with poor inbox placement - issues that can take months to fix. By following a gradual warm-up process, you'll see far better results than if you try to cut corners.

Tools like Primeforge simplify this journey. With automated DNS setup, US-based IPs, and built-in warm-up tools, Primeforge lets you focus on creating engaging content while it handles the technical side. The Forge Stack’s integrated system ensures that everything - from email infrastructure to deliverability monitoring - works together smoothly, eliminating the need to juggle multiple vendors.

Establishing a strong sender reputation takes time, but it’s far easier to build credibility from the start than to recover from a damaged reputation. By sticking to these best practices and using tools like Primeforge, you can confidently navigate the warm-up process and set yourself up for scalable, reliable email outreach that consistently lands in inboxes.

FAQs

Why should you start with a small number of emails when warming up a new IP?

When you're warming up an IP, starting with a low volume of emails is key. This approach helps build trust with Internet Service Providers (ISPs) by showing that you're a consistent and responsible sender. By slowly increasing the number of emails you send over time, ISPs can identify your IP as a reliable source, which boosts your chances of landing in inboxes rather than spam folders. This gradual process lays the foundation for better email deliverability in the long run.

How do Primeforge and Warmforge make the IP warm-up process easier for new email senders?

Primeforge and Warmforge simplify the email warm-up process by automating essential tasks like gradually ramping up email volume and ensuring domains are properly authenticated. These tools are designed to help new senders build a solid sender reputation while reducing the chances of emails landing in spam folders.

With features such as deliverability monitoring and automated configurations, Primeforge and Warmforge take the hassle out of the process. This allows businesses to save time and concentrate on achieving their outreach objectives.

What happens if I skip the IP warm-up process or send too many emails too quickly?

Skipping the IP warm-up process or rushing to send emails in large volumes can seriously hurt your email deliverability and sender reputation. If you don’t ease into it, your emails are more likely to end up flagged as spam or outright rejected by recipient servers. Over time, this can lead to bigger problems, like getting blacklisted.

This is especially risky for new senders or freshly assigned IP addresses. Sudden spikes in email activity can easily set off spam filters. By gradually warming up your IP, you improve the chances of landing in inboxes and start building trust with email providers.

Related Blog Posts

• Email Warm-Up Checklist for New Domains
• Domain Health Checklist for Cold Email Success
• Best Practices for Warming Up Domains in 2025
• Scaling Cold Emails Without Throttling Issues