Domain Health Checklist for Cold Email Success
Your domain’s health is critical for cold email success. Poor domain reputation can send your emails straight to spam, killing open rates, clicks, and conversions. Here’s the key to avoiding that:
- 77% of email deliverability issues stem from bad domain reputation.
- 1 in 6 emails never reaches the inbox, impacting engagement and ROI.
- Use SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to authenticate your emails.
- Protect your primary domain by using dedicated subdomains for outreach.
- Monitor metrics like bounce rate (<2%), spam complaints (<0.1%), and engagement rates (>20%).
- Regularly check for blacklists and update DNS records to maintain trust with email providers.
Tools like Primeforge simplify domain setup and authentication, saving time and reducing errors. By focusing on proper domain configuration and ongoing monitoring, you can improve inbox placement and boost campaign performance.
Domain Setup and Selection Best Practices
When it comes to email deliverability, the way you select and configure your domain plays a massive role in your success. A well-set-up domain not only helps your emails land in inboxes but also builds on your domain's reputation to keep your campaigns running smoothly.
Register a Clean Domain
Start by choosing a domain with no history of spam or blacklisting. Stick to trusted TLDs like .com, .co, or .io. These are widely recognized and favored by email service providers, whereas less common extensions like .xyz or .biz are more likely to trigger spam filters. Email providers have learned to associate certain TLDs with spammy behavior, so sticking to the tried-and-true options gives you a better shot at success.
Keep your domain simple. Avoid numbers and dashes - they’re red flags for spam filters. For example, a clean, professional domain like mycompany.io is much less likely to raise suspicion than something like my-company-123.biz.
Before you buy a domain, dig into its history. Tools like the Wayback Machine can help you uncover any past issues, and blacklist-checking tools ensure the domain hasn’t been flagged. Domains with a clean, long-standing history are seen as more trustworthy by email providers.
It’s also important for your domain to reflect your brand. If your business is "TechSolutions", a domain like techsolutions.co or techsol.io keeps your branding consistent while maintaining a professional and clean image.
Once your primary domain is set, it’s time to safeguard it by using subdomains for outreach.
Use a Dedicated Subdomain for Outreach
Your primary domain represents your business, so protecting it should be a top priority. By using a dedicated subdomain for cold email campaigns, you create a safety net for your main domain. This separation ensures that any deliverability issues tied to your outreach won’t impact your main domain’s operations. That way, your transactional emails, customer communications, and internal correspondence remain unaffected.
For example, if your main domain is company.com, you could create subdomains like outreach.company.com or sales.company.com. This keeps your branding consistent while clearly dividing your outreach activities from other core functions.
In some cases, industry-specific subdomains can provide an added boost. For instance, a fintech company might use fintech.company.com for campaigns targeting financial services. This not only reinforces your authority in the industry but also helps build credibility with your specific audience.
With this protective structure in place, you’re ready to move on to proper domain authentication.
Automate Domain Setup with Primeforge
Setting up DNS records manually can be tricky and prone to errors, but Primeforge simplifies the process. This platform automates DNS configuration for essential authentication protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. It’s designed to work seamlessly with Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 mailboxes, offering pre-configured DNS settings and US-based IP addresses.
Primeforge takes the guesswork out of domain configuration, helping you avoid common mistakes and get your domains ready for outreach in record time. Its bulk DNS update feature is particularly handy if you’re managing multiple domains - it allows you to update records across all of them simultaneously, saving hours of effort.
The inclusion of US-based IP addresses also gives your emails an edge. Since emails sent from domestic IPs often face less scrutiny from major providers serving US markets, this setup can improve your deliverability rates.
With your domain properly set up and authenticated, you’ll be well-positioned to achieve better inbox placement and campaign performance.
Email Authentication Protocols Setup
Email authentication protocols act like a digital ID for your domain, reassuring receiving servers that your emails are legitimate and haven’t been tampered with. Without these protocols, many email providers might flag your messages as suspicious, or worse, block them entirely.
The three main protocols - SPF, DKIM, and DMARC - work together to create a secure framework for email authentication. SPF (Sender Policy Framework) confirms that emails are sent from authorized servers. DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail) attaches a digital signature to prove the email’s authenticity. Finally, DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting & Conformance) sets rules for handling emails that fail SPF or DKIM checks. Here’s how to configure each protocol:
Set Up SPF, DKIM, and DMARC
SPF (Sender Policy Framework) ensures only approved IP addresses can send emails using your domain. To set it up, identify all services that send emails on your behalf and include them in your SPF record. For example, an SPF record might look like this:
v=spf1 include:_spf.google.com include:servers.mcsv.net ~all
In this record:
- The
includedirectives specify trusted services (e.g., Google Workspace or Mailchimp). - The
~allmechanism tells servers to treat emails from unauthorized sources with caution.
DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail) adds an encrypted signature to outgoing emails, verifying their authenticity. To enable DKIM, generate a key pair (public and private) via your email provider’s admin tools. For example, Google Workspace users can create a DKIM key in their admin console. Once generated, add the public key as a TXT record in your DNS settings.
DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting & Conformance) dictates how to handle emails that fail SPF or DKIM checks. Start with a policy of p=none to monitor email traffic and review reports. After resolving any issues, you can strengthen the policy to p=quarantine or even p=reject for stricter security.
Configure Reverse DNS and Other Key DNS Records
Reverse DNS (rDNS) maps IP addresses back to domain names, which is a critical step for email deliverability. Many email providers verify that your IP address correctly points to a domain you control - ideally matching your sending domain or subdomain.
In addition to SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, ensure your MX and CNAME records are properly set up to handle incoming mail and avoid conflicts with your authentication setup. Be aware that DNS changes can take up to 48 hours to propagate, so plan updates carefully.
Also, watch out for the SPF 10-DNS lookup limit. If your SPF record requires more than 10 DNS lookups (common with multiple third-party email services), it might fail. Tools like DMARCLY's Safe SPF can help by consolidating your SPF record to stay within the limit.
Use Primeforge for Automated DNS Updates
Manually configuring DNS records can be tedious and error-prone, especially if you’re managing multiple domains. Primeforge simplifies this process by automating the setup and management of SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records. Its bulk DNS update feature allows businesses to update records across multiple domains simultaneously, reducing errors and ensuring consistent configurations. This automation can save time and streamline your email authentication process.
Maintain IP and Domain Reputation
Once you've nailed the setup and authentication, the next step is protecting your reputation - because in the email world, your IP and domain reputation are everything. Email providers like Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo scrutinize your sending practices to decide whether your emails land in inboxes or get dumped into spam. Here's a shocking stat: 21% of emails never make it to inboxes due to poor domain reputation. A solid reputation tells email service providers (ESPs) that your messages are trustworthy and worth delivering, building on the foundation of your authentication measures.
Your reputation hinges on several factors, including spam complaint rates, engagement levels, bounce rates, and your overall sending history. Keeping tabs on these metrics is non-negotiable if you want consistent results.
Use US-Based IP Addresses
If your outreach targets US-based prospects, where your IP is located can make a big difference. US-based IP addresses are often seen as more reliable by major email providers, which can improve your deliverability and reduce the chances of being flagged as spam. Companies like Primeforge offer US-based IP addresses as part of their email infrastructure solutions, giving you an edge in both deliverability and compliance with domestic standards.
Monitor IP Blacklists and Reputation Scores
Staying off blacklists is critical. These databases track IPs and domains flagged for suspicious behavior, and landing on one can tank your deliverability. Tools like MXToolBox, Talos Intelligence, and Google Postmaster Tools can help you keep an eye on your reputation.
Here are some key metrics to monitor:
- Spam complaint rate: Keep it under 0.1%.
- Unsubscribe rate: Aim for around 0.5%.
Set up automated alerts to catch blacklist issues early. And don’t forget - email lists naturally degrade by about 22.5% each year, so regular cleaning is a must to maintain accuracy and engagement.
Separate Outreach from Transactional Emails
Keep your outreach emails separate from transactional ones by using different domains or subdomains. This way, if one domain faces issues, your core business emails remain unaffected.
"Domain reputation is the primary factor driving B2B email deliverability. Inbox providers now prioritize sender behavior, not IP address, to decide inbox placement." – Allegrow
For larger-scale operations, consider using multiple domains to spread out risk and scale your outreach without jeopardizing your primary domain's reputation. Just make sure every domain is properly configured with SPF, DKIM, and DMARC protocols to maintain authenticity and security.
sbb-itb-be7a2e3
Domain Health Monitoring and Maintenance
Setting up your domain is just the first step. The real challenge comes with keeping it in good shape through ongoing monitoring and maintenance. This is crucial because email lists naturally degrade - 22.7% of email addresses expire every year. Without consistent attention, your domain’s health can take a hit, impacting your email campaigns.
The principle is simple: "When performance is measured, performance improves. When performance is measured and reported back, the rate of improvement accelerates." Applying this to your cold email efforts means that regular tracking and adjustments can significantly boost results. This continuous care builds on the foundation you’ve already established, ensuring your domain stays in top form and your emails land where they should - your recipients' inboxes.
Track Key Performance Metrics
Keeping an eye on the right metrics is essential for understanding how email providers perceive your domain. These measurements highlight areas that need attention, helping you maintain a strong campaign performance.
- Delivery rate: This is the most critical metric. If your emails aren’t reaching inboxes, nothing else matters.
- Bounce rate: Spikes here demand immediate action. For soft bounces, use a three-strike rule - remove any address that bounces three times.
- Spam complaint rate: Keep this below 0.1% to stay in good standing with email providers. Personalizing subject lines can help; it’s been shown to increase response rates by 30.5%.
- DMARC compliance: Start with your DMARC record in monitoring mode (p=none) and review reports weekly to catch authentication issues before they affect deliverability.
- Reply and response rates: With privacy changes affecting open rate accuracy, focus on metrics like reply rates and click-through rates. Send targeted emails with concise, personalized content to improve engagement.
- Domain burn rate: This tracks how quickly your domain reputation declines. Protect it by using proper technical setups, limiting email volumes, and sending valuable, personalized content.
Run Regular Blacklist Checks and DNS Updates
To maintain these metrics, you’ll need to regularly check your DNS settings and monitor blacklist status. Being blacklisted can destroy your deliverability, and the longer you stay on a blacklist, the harder it is to recover. Tools like MXToolBox offer automated alerts and monitoring solutions, with plans ranging from $129 to $399 per month.
DNS records also require regular audits. Changes in hosting environments, registrar updates, or misconfigurations can disrupt your email authentication. Monthly DNS checks help you catch and fix these issues early, keeping your email infrastructure running smoothly.
Use Tools for Deliverability Insights
The tools you use can make a big difference in how effectively you monitor and optimize your email performance. With 45.6% of emails landing in spam folders in 2023, having the right resources is critical.
- Google Postmaster Tools: Free insights into Gmail deliverability, including domain reputation and spam rates.
- Microsoft SNDS: Provides data for Outlook, helping you monitor your sender reputation.
- Everest by Validity: Consolidates deliverability insights into a single dashboard for easier management.
- Mailtrap Email Testing: Offers 100 free email tests monthly, with paid plans starting at $14.99 for larger operations.
- GlockApps: Provides detailed deliverability analysis, with plans ranging from $85 to $185 per month. It’s rated 3.7/5 on G2 and 4.8/5 on Capterra.
For maximum effectiveness, combine pre-send and post-send monitoring. This approach not only improves deliverability but also enhances campaign performance. For instance, Shopify sellers using email deliverability tools reported a 17% higher conversion rate and a 40% lower bounce rate compared to those who didn’t.
Carin Slater, Manager of Lifecycle Email Marketing at Litmus, emphasizes the importance of regular monitoring: "Everyone's goal is obviously 100%. What we focus on is our inbox placement. We want 100% of our emails getting to the inbox, and if it drops below 90%, we're going to immediately investigate what's going on. Deliverability is a measure of the health of your email marketing program, so it's important to do regular check-ups on your domain, IP, and authentication in particular to make sure you're up-to-date, just like how we all go to the doctor each year."
With 70% of emails showing at least one spam-related issue, regular monitoring isn’t just a good idea - it’s a necessity. By maintaining the strong foundation you’ve built, you can ensure your cold email campaigns continue to perform at their best.
Compliance and List Management
Managing compliance and maintaining clean email lists are critical to safeguarding your email reputation. The rules surrounding cold email are strict, and breaking them can be incredibly costly. For example, in January 2024, the FTC updated the CAN-SPAM Act penalties to account for inflation, setting the maximum fine at $53,088 per violation. That means every email that violates the law could lead to a hefty penalty of up to $53,088.
Neglecting proper list management can also harm your email metrics. Sending messages to invalid or disengaged addresses increases bounce rates and spam complaints, which can damage your domain's reputation.
Build Opt-In and Verified Email Lists
While authentication ensures your emails are delivered, proper list management protects your reputation. A high-quality email list is your best defense against compliance issues and reputation damage. Even though cold emails aren’t strictly required to follow opt-in rules, adopting opt-in practices can help reduce spam complaints and improve your sender reputation. Always verify email addresses before adding them to your list.
Focus on quality over quantity. A smaller, targeted list of engaged recipients is far more effective than a massive list of indifferent contacts. Additionally, document how and where you collected each email address. This record can be crucial if you need to demonstrate compliance or legitimate consent during an inquiry.
Add Clear Unsubscribe Options
The CAN-SPAM Act mandates that every email includes a simple, clear way for recipients to opt out of future communications. Include an easy-to-find unsubscribe link in every email you send.
Make sure opt-out requests are processed within 10 business days. Automate this process where possible, and ensure your team understands the importance of adhering to this timeline.
Your emails should also include your company’s physical postal address. This not only complies with regulations but also builds trust by showing transparency. Additionally, include your name and company details so recipients know who is reaching out to them.
Clean and Update Lists Regularly
Even the most carefully curated email lists can deteriorate over time. Regular cleaning is essential to maintaining compliance and protecting your domain reputation. Remove hard bounces immediately. For soft bounces, apply a three-strike rule: if an address soft bounces three times, take it off your list.
Pay attention to engagement. Remove contacts who consistently ignore your emails, as disengaged recipients are more likely to mark your messages as spam, which can hurt your sender reputation.
Conduct monthly audits of your email lists to check for bounces, spam complaints, and unsubscribes. Also, be mindful of your subject lines. The CAN-SPAM Act requires that subject lines be honest and not misleading. Since 47% of recipients open emails based solely on the subject line, ensuring your subject lines accurately reflect your content is crucial for building trust.
Conclusion: Build a Strong Foundation for Cold Email Success
Every step in the checklist plays a vital role in creating a reliable foundation for your email outreach. At the heart of this process lies domain health, which ultimately determines whether your cold emails land in inboxes or get flagged as spam. A poor domain reputation can derail your efforts, with emails ending up in spam folders or, worse, your domain being blacklisted.
To avoid these pitfalls, the checklist emphasizes key actions like registering clean domains, setting up DNS authentication protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), and using dedicated subdomains. Maintaining essential metrics - keeping bounce rates below 2%, spam complaints under 0.1%, and engagement rates above 20% - signals credibility to email providers[25,26]. Regularly monitoring your domain health through blacklist checks, updating DNS settings, and tracking performance metrics ensures you can address issues before they escalate. Meeting these standards improves your deliverability and overall campaign success.
However, managing these technical elements manually can be both time-consuming and prone to errors. Tools like Primeforge simplify this process by automating DNS setup, offering US-based IP addresses, and enabling bulk updates across multiple workspaces. This automation not only reduces setup time by up to 70% but also minimizes the risk of mistakes that could harm your domain's reputation.
Although building a strong foundation requires upfront effort, the payoff is worth it. By focusing on domain registration, authentication, and consistent monitoring, you can secure better inbox placement, boost engagement rates, and ensure steady growth for your cold email campaigns. Each piece of the checklist works together to create the infrastructure needed for successful outreach.
FAQs
Why should I use a dedicated subdomain for cold email campaigns?
Using a dedicated subdomain for cold email campaigns is a smart move to safeguard your main domain’s reputation. Why? Because if your cold emails run into deliverability issues - like getting flagged as spam - it won’t affect the credibility of your primary domain, which is crucial for regular business communication.
On top of that, a dedicated subdomain can boost email deliverability. By isolating your cold email activity, you can better monitor performance and maintain a clean sender reputation. It also helps keep things organized, letting you manage cold outreach separately from your other email operations.
How does Primeforge simplify DNS setup to improve email deliverability?
Primeforge simplifies the often tedious process of configuring DNS records by automating the setup of crucial entries like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. These records play a key role in verifying your emails, helping them avoid spam filters and reach their intended recipients.
With tools like bulk DNS updates and smooth integration with popular email platforms, Primeforge not only saves you valuable time but also ensures your domain remains in good standing. This means you can focus on improving email deliverability for your cold outreach efforts without the usual technical headaches.
How can I maintain a strong domain reputation for cold email campaigns?
To keep your domain reputation strong when running cold email campaigns, it's a good idea to use a dedicated domain or subdomain just for outreach. This way, your main domain stays protected. Make sure your emails are authenticated with protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to boost trustworthiness. Also, ease into sending emails by starting with small, steady batches - this gradual approach helps warm up your domain.
Stay away from sudden increases in email volume, and focus on crafting messages that are personalized, relevant, and sent at the right time. Keep an eye on your sender reputation and email performance regularly so you can address any problems early. Tools like Primeforge can help streamline this process by offering automated DNS setup, US-based IP addresses, and a reliable email infrastructure designed for cold outreach. This setup can improve deliverability and keep your domain in good health.